20 Best Boutique Hotels in the Caribbean for a Luxurious Island Escape

When travelers think of the Caribbean, visions of turquoise waters, powdery white sands, and laid-back island vibes immediately come to mind. But beyond the mega all-inclusive resorts lies a collection of boutique hotels that deliver something more intimate, stylish, and authentic. Whether you’re dreaming of a romantic escape, a wellness retreat, or an off-the-beaten-path hideaway, these carefully curated properties blend personalized service, local culture, and world-class amenities.

Here are the 20 best boutique hotels in the Caribbean for 2025 that deserve a spot on your bucket list.

1. Jade Mountain Resort – St. Lucia

An architectural masterpiece, Jade Mountain is perched above the iconic Pitons, offering infinity pool sanctuaries, private bridges, and open-air suites with jaw-dropping views.

2. GoldenEye – Jamaica

Once the home of James Bond author Ian Fleming, GoldenEye combines history with luxury. Private villas, lagoon cottages, and a chic beachfront deliver barefoot elegance on Jamaica’s north coast.

3. Eden Roc Cap Cana – Dominican Republic

A member of Relais & Châteaux, Eden Roc offers sleek suites, private pools, and an exclusive marina location, perfect for travelers seeking sophistication and seclusion.

4. Hermitage Bay – Antigua

Nestled into lush hillsides, this all-inclusive boutique escape focuses on sustainability and wellness, with farm-to-table dining and romantic cliffside cottages.

5. The Loren at Pink Beach – Bermuda

Ultra-modern yet intimate, The Loren redefines boutique luxury with oceanfront suites, a serene spa, and some of the island’s best fine dining.

6. Cap Maison – St. Lucia

This family-owned boutique property blends colonial Caribbean charm with a modern twist. The wine cellar and cliff-top champagne zipline set it apart.

7. The House by Elegant Hotels – Barbados

An adults-only retreat on Barbados’ Platinum Coast, The House provides champagne breakfasts, private beach cabanas, and personalized ambassadors for every guest.

8. The Island House – Nassau, Bahamas

Combining boutique style with urban sophistication, The Island House is ideal for travelers who want both culture and comfort, offering a cinema, art gallery, and wellness center.

9. Hotel El Convento – Old San Juan, Puerto Rico

This historic boutique hotel, set in a 350-year-old convent, charms visitors with Spanish colonial architecture, cobblestone streets, and authentic Puerto Rican flavor.

10. Bequia Beach Hotel – St. Vincent & The Grenadines

An insider’s gem, this retro-chic boutique property combines Scandinavian design with Caribbean charm, offering a private jet service for VIP guests.

11. Zemi Beach House – Anguilla

Sitting on the pristine shores of Shoal Bay, Zemi Beach House blends modern luxury with holistic wellness, featuring a Thai-inspired spa inside a 300-year-old house.

12. Le Barthélemy Hotel & Spa – St. Barts

Sleek French sophistication meets Caribbean cool at Le Barthélemy, where each room has floor-to-ceiling ocean views and access to Michelin-inspired dining.

13. Petit St. Vincent – Private Island

This 115-acre private island boutique resort has no phones or Wi-Fi in the villas, giving guests a rare digital detox in paradise.

14. Admiral’s Inn – Antigua

Located in historic Nelson’s Dockyard, this charming boutique inn immerses guests in maritime history while offering modern comforts and a waterfront infinity pool.

15. Rockhouse Hotel – Negril, Jamaica

Carved into the cliffs of Negril, Rockhouse blends rustic eco-luxury with reggae vibes. Villas perched above the sea make it a favorite for couples and creatives.

16. Secret Bay – Dominica

Voted one of the world’s top boutique resorts, Secret Bay features six cliffside villas with private plunge pools and focuses on sustainability and seclusion.

17. Sugar Beach, A Viceroy Resort – St. Lucia

Located between the Pitons, Sugar Beach combines luxury service with natural beauty, offering private cottages and a world-class spa in a rainforest setting.

18. The Cove – Eleuthera, Bahamas

This boutique escape is famous for its pink sand beaches, chic cabanas, and laid-back luxury, perfect for couples seeking tranquility.

19. Mount Cinnamon Resort – Grenada

A colorful hillside boutique resort overlooking Grand Anse Beach, Mount Cinnamon offers stylish villas, eco-friendly dining, and a true island-lifestyle experience.

20. Hix Island House – Vieques, Puerto Rico

This eco-chic boutique property is an architectural standout, with concrete lofts that open directly to the tropical landscape, perfect for eco-conscious travelers.

Why Choose a Boutique Hotel in the Caribbean?

Unlike large resorts, boutique hotels provide personalized service, local charm, and unique experiences that reflect the soul of each island. Whether you’re celebrating a honeymoon, planning a Caribbean girls’ trip, or simply seeking a more authentic stay, these properties combine intimacy with luxury in unforgettable ways.

---